In his example, a man has a life threatening condition and requires a bone marrow. A defense of abortion cambridge studies in philosophy and. Feldman, birth control in jewish law new york, i968, part 5. It is always nice to finally see a publication in print as it can take along time from submission to acceptance til publication. The thesis of the book is that abortion is morally permissible, and it argues for this thesis by refuting all arguments for the claim that abortion isnotpermissible. A catalog record for this book is available from the british library. But this also makes boonin s defense of abortion only as good as those premises that the critics can or do already accept. We just discovered that if you go to ethics and medicine an international journal of bioethics and click on current issue volume 25. It is understandable that given the contentious nature of the subject, boonin s defense of abortion would employ such a strategy in order to make a more effective contribution to the debate. Applied ethicists and their critics 2004, is a prominent figure in contemporary applied ethics. The presidents council on bioethics and its critics presidents council on bioethics, human cloning and human dignity. His primary argument is an argument by analogy to a trolley case. Critically examining a wide array of arguments that have attempted to establish that every human fetus has a right to life, boonin posits that all of these arguments fail on.
This page intentionally left blank a defense of abortion david boonin has written the most thorough and. The premise is argued for, but, as i think, not well. The thesis of the book is that abortion is morally permissible, and it argues for this thesis by refuting all arguments for the claim that abortion isnotpermissible, on grounds that the abortion critics themselves can accept. If you have access to this journal as a benefit of membership in the sponsoring organization, log in through the member link in the right column. Prominent prolife philosopher francis beckwith called boonins book a defense of abortion arguably the most important monograph on abortion to be published in the last twenty years. In chapter 3, i examine arguments that have been offered in defense of the claim that the fetus acquires this right at various points after its conception, and argue that, by the abortion critics own standards, the. In his a defense of abortion david boonin largely misreads one of the oldest and most defensible arguments against abortion, the argument based on the fetuss rational nature.
Read the fulltext online edition of a defense of abortion 2003. Critically examining a wide range of arguments that attempt to prove that every. A defense of abortion cambridge studies in philosophy and public policy by david boonin a defense of abortion cambridge studies in philosophy and public policy by david boonin pdf, epub ebook d0wnl0ad david boonin has written the most thorough and detailed case for the moral permissibility of abortion yet published. His newest book offers us an interesting opportunity to reflect on how work in applied ethics fits into the philosophical study of race. Critically examining a wide array of arguments that have attempted to establish that every human fetus has a right to life, boonin posits that all of these arguments fail on their own terms. Elsewhere i have argued against boonins attribution of this desire to infants degrazia 2003. On the responsibility objection to thomsons argument david booninvail in her 1971 article, a defense of abortion, judith jarvis thomson defended the following thesis. The central thesis of philosopher david boonin is that the moral case against abortion can be shown to be unsuccessful on terms that critics of abortion can and do accept. David boonin has written the most thorough and detailed case for the moral permissibility of abortion yet. David boonin is the author of a defense of abortion 3. Library of congress cataloging in publication data boonin, david.
A defense of abortion cambridge studies in philosophy. David boonin has written the most thorough and detailed case for the moral permissibility of abortion yet published. Adefenseofabortion david boonin has written the most thorough and detailed case for the moral permissibility of abortion yet published. Later we will consider whether potentially sentient beings can be so harmed. Thomsonsequalreasonablenessargumentforabortionrights. David boonin, a defense of abortion a defense of abortion by david boonin. Employing a unique approach to teaching argumentation, editors david boonin and graham oddie open each chapter with an influential article that takes a strong stand on a particular issue. The palgrave handbook of philosophy and public policy. Philosopher david boonin has also made a significant contribution to this argument. Boonins defense of abortion consists almost exclusively of sophisticated critiques of a wide variety of prolife. A defense of abortion by david boonin booksamillion. Thomas hobbes and the science of moral virtue yale university 198286. Critically examining a wide range of arguments that attempt to prove that every human fetus has a right to life, he shows that each of these arguments fails on its own terms. The bojh argument was first popularized in 1971 by professor judith jarvis thomsons essay a defense of abortion from which boonin gets this books title, in which she compares the fetus to a hypothetical violinist with temporary kidney failure, who needs to connect his bloodstream to yours in order that your kidneys may maintain the.
A defense of abortion by david boonin, 2003 online research. A defense of abortion david boonin, professor of philosophy. Topics covered range from longstanding subjects of debate such as abortion, punishment, and freedom of expression, to more recent controversies such as those over gene editing, military drones. Cudd and others published david boonin, a defense of abortion. A defense of abortion find, read and cite all the research you need on researchgate. David boonin is professor of philosophy and director of the center for values and social policy at the university of coloradoboulder. He then explains how even if the fetus does have a right to life, abortion can still be shown to be. Featuring more than ninetyfive articles, it addresses standard topics such as abortion, euthanasia, capital punishment, world hunger, and animal rights and also delves into cuttingedge areas like cloning, racial profiling, same.
A defense of abortion by david boonin cambridge core. Home browse books book details, a defense of abortion. David schmidtz university of arizona boonins book is outstanding. This book gives a fascinating survey of the available information on abortion. Dec 11, 1998 david boonin s book a defense of abortion is a book written for people who seek to understand the philosophical arguments for and against abortion. In her article, a defense of abortion, judith jarvis thomson defended the following thesis. He is the author of thomas hobbes and the science of moral virtue 1994, a defense of abortion 2003, the problem of punishment 2008 should race matter. This book brings together a large and diverse collection of philosophical papers addressing a wide variety of public policy issues. It will reshape the discussion of these issues and is required reading for people doing research on racepolicies like his earlier work on punishment and abortion, boonins analyses are razor sharp, accessible, and. It will reshape the discussion of these issues and is required reading for people doing research on racepolicies like his earlier work on punishment and abortion, boonins analyses are razor sharp, accessible, and interesting. I offer two lines of counterargument to his argument by analogy. David boonins book a defense of abortion is a book written for people who seek to understand the philosophical arguments for and against abortion.
A defense of abortion david boonin has written the most thorough and detailed case for the moral permissibility of abortion yet published. David boonin, author of a defense of abortion 2002 and the problem of punishment 2008 and coeditor of the textbook whats wrong. Aug 29, 2005 david boonin has written the most thorough and detailed case for the moral permissibility of abortion yet published. Jul 15, 2009 professor david boonin began this debate with an analogy which illustrated the difference between accepting that someone, or something, has a right a life and accepting that this entity has an automatic right to have their life supported by a particular person. A defense of abortion by david boonin, 2003 online. Applied ethicists and their critics presents a thorough and engaging exploration of these complex questions and twentyfour other contemporary ethical issues. A defense of abortion cambridge studies in philosophy and public policy by boonin, david 2002 paperback on. A defense of abortion cambridge studies in philosophy and public policy by boonin, david 2002 paperback. To some, the book might appear overly technical and longwinded, but it must be said that the complex nature of the issues surrounding abortion demands nothing less than the kind of meticulous. Critically examining a wide range of arguments that attempt to prove that every human fetus has a right to life, he shows. The palgrave handbook of philosophy and public policy david.
Professor david boonin began this debate with an analogy which illustrated the difference between accepting that someone, or something, has a right a life and accepting that this entity has an automatic right to have their life supported by a particular person. Further reproduction prohibited without permission. On the responsibility objection to thomsons argument, ethics, vol. Applied ethicists and their critics is a thorough and engaging introduction to applied ethics that covers virtually all of the issues in the field. David boonin david boonin has written the most thorough and detailed case for the moral permissibility of abortion yet published. David boonin professor of philosophy university of colorado boulder director, center for values and social policy editor, public affairs quarterly david.
231 330 589 1217 1205 325 1185 1079 23 180 1333 1250 1363 306 1503 1169 663 657 674 263 420 558 1258 246 1374 414 718 80 900 1430 1372 418 829 379 1164 1276 959 502 248 329 547 1489 1378